← All courses

Decide What to Make Next, and When to List It

Find ideas buyers already want, check them before you buy materials, and plan your year on one page.

Research, validate and time new products, and decide with a scorecard whether to make, park or drop each idea.

44 lessons11 modules4 hr 18 min of materialFree, always
Sign in to start the free course

One free sign in on the courses page opens every mySHOP course. We email you a 6 digit code to confirm your address, then bring you right back here. Use the same email on any device to pick up where you left off.

What’s inside

5 parts, 11 modules. Start at the beginning, or go straight to what’s costing you sales.

Part 1 · Where good ideas come from

Why ideas fail, and what you're allowed to sell

  • Why most product ideas fail, and how to stop guessing
  • What you're allowed to sell
Part 2 · Reading demand

The words buyers type, what already sells, and the gap

  • The words buyers type
  • Reading what already sells
  • Finding the gap
Part 3 · Checking before you commit

A cheap test and a margin check

  • Validate before you buy materials
  • Will it pay you?
Part 4 · Timing

Seasons, lead time and a 12-month calendar

  • Evergreen, seasonal and trending
  • Lead time is part of the product
  • Your 12-month make-and-list calendar
Part 5 · The decision

Make it, park it or drop it

  • Capstone: make it, park it or drop it

Every module and lesson

44 lessons, each with a practical step, and a short quiz at the end of every module.

Module 1: Why most product ideas fail, and how to stop guessing

Most product ideas that flop on Etsy were well made and aimed at the wrong place. This module names the three reasons ideas fail, sets out the four checks this course teaches, and gets you to a list of 20 ideas to test.

  • The three reasons ideas flop
  • Demand, competition, margin and timing: the four checks
  • What Etsy buyers come for
  • Your idea list: 20 ideas before you judge any

Module 2: What you're allowed to sell

An idea Etsy won't allow is not a product idea, however many people search for it. This module runs your idea list through the Creativity Standards, the Prohibited Items Policy, the Intellectual Property Policy and the disclosure rules before you research demand.

  • Made, designed, handpicked or sourced
  • Prohibited and restricted items
  • Trademarks, fan art and characters: the fastest way to lose a listing
  • Items made with artificial intelligence, and production partners

Module 3: The words buyers type

Buyers tell you what they want every time they search. This module shows you three free places to collect their words, the search bar, Marketplace Insights and your own Stats, and how to turn a search phrase into a product idea.

  • Search suggestions as a free demand signal
  • Marketplace Insights, used well
  • Your own shop's search terms
  • Turning a search into a product idea

Module 4: Reading what already sells

Learn to read the listings already on Etsy: which signals mean real sales, how to count the competition that matters, where the price gaps are, and how to run all of it as a 20-minute scan.

  • Signals on a listing: reviews, favorites and badges
  • Counting competition without panicking
  • Price bands: where a product sits and where the gap is
  • A 20-minute market scan

Module 5: Finding the gap

Turn what you learned about existing listings into a specific product idea: mine other sellers' reviews, look for gaps by buyer, occasion, size, color and material, use personalization well, and learn when an empty search is a warning.

  • Other sellers' reviews are free research
  • Gaps by buyer, occasion, size, color and material
  • Personalization and custom as a gap
  • When "no competition" means "no demand"

Module 6: Validate before you buy materials

An idea that passed your demand and competition checks is still a guess. This module shows you how to test it for a few dollars, list the test honestly, read the result in Stats and ask the people who already like your work, without breaking Etsy's rules.

  • The smallest test that tells you something
  • Listing a test product honestly
  • What counts as a result, and how long to wait
  • Asking your existing buyers and followers without breaking the rules

Module 7: Will it pay you?

An idea can have demand and still lose you money. This module walks through the margin check with Etsy's real fees, the price buyers expect, the costs sellers forget, and the numbers that turn a maybe into go, park or drop.

  • The margin check before you make one
  • Price points buyers expect in your niche
  • Hidden costs: time, packaging, shipping and returns
  • The go, park or drop numbers

Module 8: Evergreen, seasonal and trending

Every product has a shape across the year. Learn to tell evergreen from seasonal from trend, and to read when interest actually starts rising.

  • Evergreen: bought on an ordinary Tuesday
  • Seasonal: a peak and a drop, and why late is the same as never
  • Trends: how to ride one without being left with stock
  • Using free outside tools to see when interest rises

Module 9: Lead time is part of the product

A good seasonal idea listed late is a bad idea. Count back from when buyers start looking, and plan your hours, suppliers and photos to hit that date.

  • Count back from when buyers start looking, not from the holiday
  • Your hands are a constraint: capacity planning
  • Materials, suppliers and the long pole
  • Photos and listing time

Module 10: Your 12-month make-and-list calendar

Put your whole year of making and listing on one page. Balance steady sellers against seasonal peaks, grow new products from the ones already selling, and retire the ones that aren't.

  • One page, twelve rows
  • Balancing evergreen and seasonal across the year
  • Building a product line from your best sellers
  • Retiring what doesn't sell

Module 11: Capstone: make it, park it or drop it

Everything in this course fits on one page. Score any idea in 15 minutes, see three ideas reach three different decisions, and set up a 30-minute monthly habit so you never run out of ideas again.

  • The one-page idea scorecard
  • Running three ideas through it
  • Park is for the right idea in the wrong month
  • Your research habit: 30 minutes a month

More free courses for Etsy sellers